Moscow had no stake in Catalan independence — the point was to make the European Union look like it was cracking apart from the inside.
When Catalonia held a disputed independence referendum on October 1, 2017, Spanish police baton charges and a constitutional crisis dominated international headlines — and Russian state media outlets RT and Sputnik moved quickly to amplify both, publishing in Spanish and English to cast Spain as an authoritarian state suppressing a democratic vote. Independent researchers later found that roughly a quarter of Twitter traffic about the referendum showed signs of bot amplification, and that RT and Sputnik stories were disproportionately represented among the most-shared links. Spanish investigators identified the operation as part of what analysts call “the combination” — a Soviet-era term for blending genuine grievances, real footage, and fabricated claims into a single narrative that is harder to debunk than an outright lie because much of it is true. Moscow had no material stake in Catalan independence itself; researchers concluded the operation’s real objective was to portray the European Union as fractured and hypocritical on self-determination, weakening the bloc’s credibility rather than actually helping Catalonia secede.
A Referendum and a Ready-Made Narrative
Spain’s constitutional court had declared Catalonia’s October 1, 2017 independence referendum illegal, and when national police used force to shut down polling stations, the resulting images of baton charges against voters became instantly viral. Russian state media did not need to fabricate footage — genuine video of police violence provided ample material — but researchers found RT and Sputnik’s Spanish- and English-language coverage was calibrated to maximize the story’s use as evidence of European hypocrisy, running headlines emphasizing police violence against peaceful voters while largely omitting the illegality of the vote under Spanish law.
Measuring the Amplification
Academic analysis of the referendum’s Twitter traffic, cited in reporting by CNN, found that automated accounts generated roughly 23.5% of the 3.6 million tweets posted about the October 1 vote — a scale of bot activity well above normal background levels for a comparably sized European political event. Spain’s then-foreign minister publicly stated the government had intelligence pointing to Russian-based networks amplifying the crisis, and a subsequent judicial investigation led by Spanish judge Joaquín Aguirre, detailed by CEPA, examined the role of Russian disinformation and troll and bot farms in the referendum’s online amplification.
“The Combination”
Researchers at Spain’s Elcano Royal Institute described the operation using a term with Soviet-era origins: “the combination”, a technique for blending authentic material, real political grievances, and fabricated additions into a single narrative package. Genuine footage of police violence was mixed with invented claims — including false reports that the European Union had endorsed Catalan independence, and a fabricated story claiming Catalonia intended to formally recognize Russia’s annexation of Crimea. Because the combination technique embeds fabrications inside otherwise accurate reporting, it is considerably harder to debunk in full than a story invented from nothing, since retracting the false elements does not discredit the true ones.
Denials at the Top, Amplification Below
The scale of the coverage was substantial: Spanish counterintelligence officials described the volume of Russian disinformation about Catalonia and Spain as “shameless,” with as many as 50 false or biased stories appearing daily at the height of the crisis, according to reporting compiled by Vocal Europe. That volume sat awkwardly alongside Moscow’s official public position: Newsweek reported that President Vladimir Putin, Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, and Russia’s ambassador in Madrid all publicly affirmed Russia’s “total support” for Spain’s territorial integrity and denied any interest in the internal dispute — a gap between elite diplomatic messaging and grassroots media amplification that researchers say is typical of Russian information operations, which are built to be deniable at the state level even while state-funded outlets do the actual work of amplification underneath.
Not Alone: The Venezuela Link
Reporting by the Daily Beast found that Venezuelan state-linked accounts amplified pro-Catalan-independence content alongside Russian sources, suggesting coordination — or at least mutual reinforcement — between two governments with a shared interest in portraying Western liberal democracies as unstable and hypocritical on questions of self-determination and state violence.
Strategic Purpose, Not Catalan Sympathy
Analysts who studied the campaign, including at CEPA and in coverage collected by Vocal Europe, concluded Moscow had no genuine interest in an independent Catalonia — a state Russia has never recognized or shown diplomatic inclination to support. The operation’s value to the Kremlin was instrumental: a fracturing Spain and a discredited EU, unable to manage self-determination demands within its own borders, provided a ready comparison for Russian officials seeking to deflect Western criticism of Russia’s own record on regions like Chechnya, Crimea, and separatist territories in Georgia and Ukraine.
Outcome
Catalonia’s declared independence was never recognized internationally and Madrid imposed direct rule on the region within weeks of the vote, but the disinformation campaign achieved a more durable secondary effect: it became one of the first widely documented cases of Russian information operations targeting a Western European domestic political crisis rather than an election or a foreign policy dispute directly involving Russia, establishing a template — amplify genuine unrest, blend it with fabrication, aim at EU credibility — that reappeared in later operations targeting protest movements and pandemic-era unrest across the continent.
Leave a Reply